Tignanello vs Sassicaia
By Master Chef Gianluca Deiana Abis
1. History and Origin
Tignanello:
Produced by Marchesi Antinori, Tignanello was introduced in 1971 as a groundbreaking Super Tuscan. It was among the first Tuscan wines to abandon the strict Chianti Classico regulations of the time, omitting white grapes and incorporating Bordeaux varietals. The result was a new, modern style that blended Sangiovese with Cabernet Sauvignon and Cabernet Franc, showing the world that Tuscany could produce international-caliber wines outside of traditional guidelines. Tignanello comes from the Tignanello estate in the heart of Chianti Classico, and it’s widely recognized as a trailblazer that helped establish the Super Tuscan movement.
Sassicaia:
Sassicaia, produced by Tenuta San Guido in Bolgheri, was introduced earlier than Tignanello, with its first commercial vintage in 1968. The wine’s creation marked the start of the Super Tuscan era. Mario Incisa della Rocchetta planted Cabernet Sauvignon and Cabernet Franc vines in the 1940s, believing the Bolgheri terroir was well-suited to Bordeaux-style grapes. Initially produced for private consumption, Sassicaia’s success inspired an entire region, eventually leading to the creation of Bolgheri DOC. Sassicaia is the only Italian wine with its own DOC (Bolgheri Sassicaia), highlighting its unique stature in Italian wine history.
2. Grape Varieties and Composition
Tignanello:
Typically a blend of around 80% Sangiovese with the remainder split between Cabernet Sauvignon and Cabernet Franc. The Sangiovese core gives it a distinctly Tuscan character, while the Bordeaux varietals add structure and depth.
Sassicaia:
A classic Bordeaux-style blend, dominated by Cabernet Sauvignon (about 85%) and balanced with Cabernet Franc. It’s known for its elegant structure, minerality, and aging potential.
3. Body and Alcohol Content
Tignanello:
Medium to full-bodied with alcohol levels around 13.5% to 14%. It balances bright acidity and firm tannins, offering a fresher, more vibrant profile due to its significant Sangiovese component.
Sassicaia:
Full-bodied and structured, Sassicaia often shows slightly higher alcohol levels, typically between 14% and 14.5%. It is known for its silky texture, pronounced minerality, and seamless integration of tannins.
4. Flavor Profile
Tignanello:
Bright red cherry, blackcurrant, and plum are accompanied by hints of tobacco, spice, and dried herbs. The Sangiovese provides lively acidity and a more distinctly Tuscan flavor profile, with elegant notes of oak and a long finish.
Sassicaia:
Blackcurrant, blackberry, and dark cherry dominate, with layers of cedar, graphite, and mint. The coastal influence adds a subtle saline minerality, while its Bordeaux-style blend offers depth, complexity, and a refined, polished character.
5. Aging Potential
Tignanello:
While it can age beautifully for 10–15 years, Tignanello is often appreciated for its vibrant youthfulness within the first decade.
Sassicaia:
With a reputation for extraordinary longevity, Sassicaia can evolve for 15–20 years or more, developing complex tertiary aromas and deeper, more nuanced flavors over time.
6. Food Pairing
Tignanello:
Pairs wonderfully with traditional Tuscan cuisine—pasta with wild boar ragù, bistecca alla Fiorentina, and truffle-infused dishes. Its bright acidity also complements tomato-based sauces and aged Pecorino cheese.
Sassicaia:
Best suited to refined dishes such as roast lamb, braised short ribs, and duck breast with berry reduction. Its elegance and structure make it an excellent match for richer, complex recipes and aged Parmigiano Reggiano.
7. Cultural Impact
Tignanello:
A groundbreaking wine that changed the way the world viewed Chianti and Tuscan winemaking, Tignanello is a symbol of innovation, proving that tradition can be redefined without losing its soul.
Sassicaia:
The first wine to establish Bolgheri as a premier region for Bordeaux varietals, Sassicaia is considered a trailblazer in Italian winemaking, creating a new benchmark for elegance, refinement, and international acclaim.
8. Conclusion
Tignanello and Sassicaia represent two different, yet complementary sides of Tuscany’s revolutionary winemaking. Tignanello maintains a firm connection to Tuscan tradition through its Sangiovese core, offering bright acidity and a fresh, food-friendly profile. Sassicaia, with its Bordeaux-inspired blend, showcases the elegance and sophistication that Bolgheri’s unique terroir can produce. Both wines stand as icons in the world of Super Tuscans, and each offers its own distinct interpretation of what makes Tuscany a world-class wine region.
Comments